RIP Barry Rubin

Barry Rubin passed away earlier this year on Feb 3, 2014.

2003 was a hallmark year for me in my research on the Georgetown Branch. Up until that point, I had spent much of my time hunting around online for Sanborn maps, looking at old aerial photos and maps of the line, trying to decode the various phases and stages of the construction of the line. Unraveling the mystery, as I like to say, which I still am doing to this day. Around this time I became involved with the B&O RR Historical Society and joined the popular related Yahoo group. Worlds opened as I met many new B&O enthusiasts eager to share information, ideas and recollections. I had members mailing me photos, form 6’s, maps, drawings and other pieces of data that I had never seen. The web was growing.

One day I heard that there was a B&ORRHS member, Duane Carrell, who was planning on writing an article about the Georgetown Branch. Imagine my excitement. I mean, here I was, trying as hard as I could to dig up information on the line, and there was another nut just like me who was writing an article about it! I was thrilled. Then came the emails that really locked everything in for me. Barry Rubin, who at the time was involved with the Society, decided that with all the interest in the Georgetown Branch, perhaps we should have a get-together, a sort of meet-and-greet. He offered up his house as a location and we put it on the books.

On a very cold January morning, I showed up not knowing what I’d find or who I’d meet, or that it would be the seminal turning point for opening up my eyes to the depth of the history of the Branch. Duane, who was writing the article, showed up and brought with him all of his source materials. There were original track chart blueprints, maps, huge collections of black and white photos, overhead aerials, notes, and a variety of other plans and documents. ALL about the Georgetown Branch. I was just overwhelmed with excitement and remember poring over each and every page and photo, knowing that none of these were going home with me so I had better soak it all up now.

Barry then led us, caravan style, from his home in Chevy Chase down to Bethesda, where we parked at River Rd. and walked a short distance both North and South down the old right-of-way, describing track alignments, old buildings that remained, remnants of sidings and ghosts of operations gone by. We had a GREAT time and we all became friends as we shared in an enthusiasm for this little old railroad branch line.

Jan 18, 2003, Bethesda MD. The first (and only) Georgetown Branch get-together. From left to right: Kelly Regan, C.E. Close, Duane Carrell, Barry Rubin, Daniel Rubin and Joe Nevin.

Barry was the impetus for that meet-up. He took the time to get everyone together, offering his house and his leadership. He did so much outside of this silly little meeting, but for me it was one of the most important in my quest as a historian and a fan of the Georgetown Branch, the B&O and the people of the B&ORRHS. It’s the people that I meet, who put in time and effort to share and foster that energy and excitement that carries the legacy of the B&O on for future generations to enjoy and discover. For this, I thank you, Barry. Safe home.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barry_Rubin

Duane Carrell wrote the following obituary on the B&ORRHS Yahoo Group:

I wanted to let the members of the chat know that Barry Rubin, titular editor of the Sentinel, passed away this morning in Tel Aviv.  He had been fighting cancer for over a year-and-a-half.

I met Barry when we entered 7th grade in 1961 at Alice Deal Jr. High in Washington and we became fast friends in the ninth grade when we discovered that we each had an interest in railroads.  I was with him when he bought his first train set in downtown Washington on the day that President Kennedy was assassinated.  A year later we joined the Rockville Society of Model Engineers and his father often drove us to meetings.  By our senior year our interests had diverged somewhat although we remained friends.  He went to Georgetown Univ. and became a history professor and also worked for the Democrats in the U.S. Senate.  I saw him briefly at our 20th high school reunion in 1987 and then lost touch for another 14 years.  In the meantime he had developed a deep interest in Israel and Mideast affairs and moved to Tel Aviv, although he kept a residence in Chevy Chase for lengthy visits here.  In 2001 I happened to see his name in the masthead of the Sentinel as the editor, wondered if it could be the same person and emailed him.  Lo and behold it was and we re-kindled a long-dormant friendship and became very close.  It was Barry who made me aware of the yahoo group and encouraged me to write for the Sentinel.  And, as history sometimes repeats itself, Barry took part in his first Civil War reenactment with me three years ago in Olustee, Florida.

 Barry became an authority on Middle East Affairs, founded the Global Research in International Affairs Center, wrote close to 20 books – most on the Middle East – and traveled the world, speaking to government and private groups about the state of the Middle East.  He was extremely professional in his analysis and did not let his opinions get in the way of the facts.  He did not back away from stating the truth and made some enemies for it.

 He was diagnosed with cancer in July, 2012, appeared to be beating it and more appeared in recent months.  He married somewhat late in life and leaves his wife, Judy, an 18-year old daughter who is performing public service in Israel and a 14-year-old son.  I have no word on funeral arrangements yet.

 He will be missed.

 Duane Carrell

Very short film clip of Georgetown in the 50s

I’m a complete sucker for media showing the Georgetown Branch in its heyday, and get pretty excited when it’s of the film/video variety. There are simply not that many films in existence which depict the branch in service! There are fabled copies of a film showing the fan trip down the line in the late 40s held by the NRHS but I haven’t even been able to get a reply from them on this.
Anyway, in this film which is a snippet of a collection of aerial footage of DC in 1954 shows the Georgetown waterfront area for the first 23 seconds. Not that great, it’s wobbly, but it’s there. Note the aqueduct bridge footings, still in place in the river (Army Corps of Engineers had yet to demolish them), the Lone Star cement factory standing tall and the Hopfmaier rendering plant smoking away across from the Wilkins Rogers mill. The power plant is still standing and the coal steam plant can be seen in the background near the end of the line. Very cool!
http://www.criticalpast.com/video/65675050411_Potomac-River_Lincoln-Memorial_Jefferson-Memorial_National-Airport_Key-Bridge

Some eBay finds, including an interesting building feature.

I hope you find these photos I recently purchased on eBay as interesting as I do!

May 15, 1947, Fatal Bus Accident
“BETHESDA, MD- Three persons were reported killed and at least five injured when a B&O freight train struck a private bus at a grade crossing here today (5/14). One of the victims is shown being removed from the wreckage. ACME TELEPHOTO” 

I wrote about this previously here.

March 19, 1936, Potomac Floods Capital Area
“POTOMAC FLOODS CAPITAL AREA, An aerial view of Georgetown, Historic spot of Washington, D.C., Submerged in flood waters of the swollen Potomac. The building with the two smoke stacks is the city’s gas plant which probably will be out of commission soon, thus leaving the city without gas. 3/19/1936”
I’m curious if that power plant was ever gas powered. I always thought it was coal-fired. Hmm…
March 19, 1936, Georgetown Flooded
“GEORGETOWN FLOODED, A view from the air of Georgetown, in the District of Columbia, several feet under water due to the rising waters of the Potomac. It is estimated that the Potomac has left $5,000,000 property damage in its wake. 3/19/1936”

Interesting to note the rail cars left in the yard as well as the buildings along Water Street. Also note the trails of stains in the water from the industrial area.

October 17, 1942, District of Columbia Flooded
“DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA FLOODED, Washington, D.C. – “K” street in Georgetown, D.C., was submerged by the flood waters of the Potomac today. The river can be seen at upper right. 10/17/1942″ 

Note the giant beer bottle sign on the corner of the building at left. Also the Lone Star cement plant to the right and the Wilkins Rogers milling building in the distance. My favorite has to be the big beer bottle advertisement on the corner of the building in the lower-left hand corner of the bottom image. This was most likely for Brenizer Brewing Co. which maps indicate was located on this site.

 

Relics From The Past: A Mystery Wreck on the Branch

Last spring I was contacted by someone who had made a discovery along the Georgetown Branch. Just North of the Dalecarlia tunnel some folks were clearing invasive species brush from the park area just around the trail. While going through the brush, they uncovered this:

Mysterious wreck on the GB.
Frame of a freight car. Photo from David Cohen.
Frame of two more freight cars. Photo from David Cohen.
Frame of two more freight cars. Photo from David Cohen.

There have been a couple blog posts pop up (one here)covering the discovery, but no solid information on the wreck itself has arisen. I’ve had discussions with a few other railfans and friends and aside from a few clues this is a mystery.

Here’s what we know: the cars are likely freight cars. There are apparently no trucks, bolsters or couplers. They appear to have been torched off (and presumably removed). The one car nearest to the trail dates from 1935-1950. Jeffrey Ramone writes: It’s definitely from a car that was built between 35 and 50. New York Air Brake equipment, AB valve…way cool.” J. D. Hathaway writes: “I’m told the car was built after 1934 because of the type of brakes. The cylinder and various things are all part of the “AB” type air brake system”.   It’s unlikely these were hopper cars, as the subframe is clearly from a car that has a solid frame beneath. Boxcars, gondolas, flatcars are all possibilities. It’s most likely a 40′ car. Some more sleuthing is necessary to really get to the bottom of it.

Why are the cars there? This is the biggest mystery. Several theories have arisen. My best guess is that they were part of a wreck in this area at some point. Something akin to a messy derailment. There were no injuries so perhaps there was no public report. The cars were simply torched in place to salvage some of the materials and parts and the rest left to rot. Obviously an air brake system can’t be reused after it’s suffered damage in a wreck.

Perhaps the economics of the time dictated that the underframes were the least valuable parts and were left behind. Perhaps the crew was called away on another job and this was simply forgotten. I doubt these were placed here intentionally, ie on a siding of some kind. Due to the dates on the cars there should be a report of the wreck somewhere. I will keep searching! If you come across any additional information, please share it here!

CCT North side 1
Photo by J.D. Hathaway
CCT North side 3
Photo by J.D. Hathaway
CCT South side 1
Photo by J.D. Hathaway
CCT South side 2
Photo by J.D. Hathaway
CCT North side 5
Photo by J.D. Hathaway
CCT North side 4
Photo by J.D. Hathaway
CCT South side 3
Photo by J.D. Hathaway
CCT North side 2
Photo by J.D. Hathaway

 

Monorail! Monorail! Monorail!

Channeling the classic episode of The Simpsons, were you aware that the corridor from Bethesda to Silver Spring could have been a monorail type train, known as an Aeromovel? This odd type of transport uses compressed air to “push” the train along on an elevated platform, and was considered as an alternative for reuse of the Georgetown Branch between the two cities. A study was done and a copy can be found in the Chevy Chase Historical Society archives. http://chevychasehistory.pastperfectonline.com/library/37E6A661-EAA1-4262-BBB2-190821234210

GB Corridor Study Aeromovel
GB Corridor Study for the Aeromovel Alternative, 1989

 

 

Layout: Progress at Georgetown Junction & Bethesda

Got a bit of work done on the layout today. Laid down more roadbed at Georgetown Junction and laid in the sub roadbed (Homasote) in Bethesda. Did some thinking about track laid flush on the sub roadbed in Bethesda vs. laying it on roadbed. I was originally leaning toward all on the sub roadbed itself but thinking about Bethesda there was a nice track profile on much of it. This will be tricky. I do have some large Homabed panels that would work but I think it may be a waste here. We will see! Going to study some more photos and make a decision. Progress is good!

IMG_6898 IMG_6897 IMG_6896 IMG_6894 IMG_6892 IMG_6891

Layout Notes: Knife-Edge Blades For Cutting Homasote

Bosch T113A3
Bosch T113A3

I purchased a 3-pack of these Bosch T113A3 4″ T-shank jigsaw blades to make a go at cutting some 1/2″ Homasote that I will be using as subroadbed on the layout. My intent was to avoid the legendarily bad dust that is created using conventional wood-cutting, teethed blades. I have seen these type of blades around  but never given one a shot.

My initial impression was that the blade appears to be sharp and is wedge-shaped. It loaded easily in my DeWalt jigsaw and operated well. The initial cut into the Homasote was smooth and steady, to be expected and at first it seemed that it would work well. There was little dust. However, there was another problem. Smoke. Yep, after about 3-4″ the material started smoking heavily. I removed the blade from the material and the blade itself had burn marks on it. I switched to a regular wood-cutting blade and went back to cutting and it all worked out fine.

TL:DR: Knife-edge jigsaw blades are inappropriate for cutting Homasote. Stick with wood-cutting blades outside, with plenty of ventilation and preferably with a breeze to blow the dust away. Wear a mask!

Fatal Bus Accident on the Branch in 1947 – UPDATED

While perusing my daily eBay alerts I have set up for items that come across the auction block, I came across one I had never seen or even heard of before. Apparently on May 16, 1947 there was a fatal accident on the Georgetown Branch somewhere in Bethesda in which a train struck a private passenger bus, killing three persons and injuring five. The bus appears in the photo on its side, along the tracks, wrapped in chains and surrounded by emergency personnel. The caption reads that the photo shows one of the victims being removed; you can see them wrapped in white, on a stretcher, being carried off in the center of the image. A nonetheless, a tragic and fascinating reminder that even though the Branch had relatively little traffic in its later years, earlier on it was much busier, the track in better condition, and trains no doubt were moving faster. I have read about a few other occasions where people and vehicles were struck along the line.

05-16-1947 GB Bethesda Bus Accident press photo frontThe location has me stumped. I’m fairly certain it’s not in downtown Bethesda. It appears to be a single track so may have been over by River Rd. or Kenwood (Dorset Rd.).  Perhaps some of the roads just north of Bethesda crossed at grade. I would have to dig around some old aerials and maps to see. Would love your input or any feedback on this! (*photos from eBay)

05-16-1947 GB Bethesda Bus Accident press photo backEDIT: UPDATE
Well, that didn’t take long. I posted a link to this blog post on the wonderful Bethesda Chevy Chase Back In The Day Facebook group and within minutes the mystery was solved.  Seems the bus was owned by the Congressional Country Club and was crossing Dorset Avenue when a train struck the bus. Passengers were employees from the CC being taken to the local trolley trolley terminal at Tenley Circle. I would wager that the train was traveling as it normally did, caboose-first, when it struck the bus. First up, it would have been relatively quiet as the business end of the train (the engine/loco) was far away, pushing the train. Second, I don’t know for sure but I believe they would not have blown the whistle or flagged the small Dorset Ave. crossing. Partially because the crossing would have been very minor back then and the neighbors probably wouldn’t have liked it too much. HUGE thanks to Jerry P. for making the pull and finding the following Washington Star sources! Jerry notes that the casualties were caused not as much by the impact, but rather the people attempting to escape from the bus as it was pushed down the tracks by the freight train.

May 15, 1947 Evening Star - bus accident photo
May 15, 1947 Evening Star – bus accident photo
May 16, 1947 Evening Star - bus accident follow-up article
May 16, 1947 Evening Star – bus accident follow-up article

Postcard View of Rock Creek Trestle, ca 1908

Rock Creek Trestle, ca 1908
Rock Creek Trestle, ca 1908. Photo from eBay.

I have several email alerts set up for items on eBay which match Georgetown Branch related places and subjects. When one comes up, it’s always exciting, especially something I have never seen before. Here is a perfect example. This view of the Rock Creek Trestle is by no means stellar, but it is something new and from a time period that  is somewhat of a transition for the GB. It was around this time that the B&O extended the fill on both ends of this trestle, burying the pilings and shortening the elevated section by quite a bit. They were extending the line from Chevy Chase on down to Bethesda, Dalecarlia and into Georgetown. At the same time the tunnel under Conduit Rd. (MacArthur Blvd) was being built and the stone arch in Georgetown was being extended. This was the era in which the Branch as we know it was being “built”. A lot was happening and this is one small, quiet moment from that era.

 

 

View of Water St., Georgetown, ca. 1930

Aqueduct Bridge vignette, ca 1930
Aqueduct Bridge vignette, ca 1930

A fantastic and very rare view of Georgetown from beneath the Aqueduct bridge arch looking down Water St. You can see many things here including the new Key Bridge, the end of the Belgian block pavers that lined the street prior to it being converted to concrete and many of the waterfront buildings. An impressive view! (via the Old Time DC Facebook page)

View the image here at the Library of Congress: “Train tracks near Potomac River, Washington, D.C.